Twenty-nine Puntland political figures have warned against constitutional amendments in the name of consensus. Their November 13 letter, issued under the name Council of Puntland Politicians and Intellectuals, invokes exclusion, past violence and the rights of founding constituencies. It offers no evidence that the ongoing parliamentary review has excluded those constituencies, identifies no breached constitutional procedure and proposes no practical alternative. That omission matters because the legislature has already been consulting political figures, academics and civil society. The authors' central demand arrives without an assessment of what has actually been done. The signed document offers neither dates nor examples of rejected requests to participate. Against a documented committee process, its language of marginalisation becomes a political assertion whose evidentiary burden the authors leave entirely unmet in public.

On October 7, Puntland parliament's special committee consulted the electoral commission. On October 19 it met university representatives. It held a meeting with residents of Galkacyo on October 29, according to the assembly's own record. Horseed Media reported a further meeting with former officeholders on November 3. On November 12, the committee presented its findings to parliament and described discussions with government institutions and civil-society groups. These activities do not establish that everyone was heard. They establish that consultation was under way. Anyone alleging exclusion should identify who was left out, when participation was refused and which decision was consequently compromised.

The letter supplies none of those particulars. Instead it asks that all constituencies involved in Puntland's founding gather for broader talks. Even this apparently expansive proposal conceals a problem. Who qualifies as a founding constituency? Who chooses its delegates? What place would the young, women and residents who never attended the meetings of 1998 receive? A former minister's signature is evidence of an opinion, not proof of a public mandate. The authors give the reader no reason to treat their self-described council as a representative institution.

They also neglect the relevant legal machinery. Article 139 of Puntland's 2023 constitution sets out a route for amendments: proposals, special-committee examination, public information, parliamentary deliberation and a specified ratification majority, with referendums required for certain foundational provisions. The signatories cite no paragraph of that procedure as violated. Nor do they identify a vote taken prematurely or an information requirement demonstrably ignored. To say that consultation should occur is easy. The constitutional question is whether the prescribed forms of consultation have occurred adequately, and what lawful consequences follow if they have not.

The government's proposal reportedly concerns nine articles, touching elections, political parties, citizen rights, executive powers and the judiciary. Such subjects demand scrutiny. Yet the letter addresses none of them by number. Does it challenge a change to the electoral timetable, the conditions for registering parties or the vice-president's authority? Does it object to provisions affecting courts? The absence of a clause-by-clause response leaves the public with a warning detached from the actual text. Constitutional argument requires more than declaring constitutional reform dangerous.

The authors invoke SSC-Khaatumo, now administering territory previously treated as part of Puntland, as another reason for delay. They may be raising questions of representation, jurisdiction and constitutional geography. They do not say which provisions have become unworkable, what boundary of authority they would recognize or which people's consent must be sought. An institutional change outside Puntland's control does not automatically make every proposed domestic amendment premature. The relationship must be demonstrated, rather than assumed.

The letter's darkest passage recalls the violence of 2023. That history warrants a specific account of what failed: negotiation, policing, electoral guarantees or confidence in institutions. The signatories provide none. Instead they suggest that accelerated reform could bring another confrontation. Such a possibility is a warning, not a constitutional argument. If the prospect of unrest is allowed to displace a decision rule, those most prepared to threaten disorder could acquire influence that the constitution never gave them.

None of this gives parliament a free pass. The committee's consultation records, proposed clauses and responses to objections should be accessible. The legislature must demonstrate compliance with Article 139, particularly its public-information requirements and voting safeguards. The authors could contribute to that scrutiny by publishing an annotated critique, identifying excluded groups and requesting specific remedies. They have chosen an appeal to unspecified consensus without the analysis needed to make that appeal operational.

The claim to speak for Puntland's political settlement is especially doubtful when its proposed decision procedure remains invisible. Broad agreement sounds attractive until citizens disagree. Then an institution must determine who has standing, which objections matter and when a lawful vote can proceed. The signatories offer no answers. Their appeal to what they call the danger of exclusion establishes neither exclusion nor a remedy. Puntland's political future requires enforceable constitutional rules, not an undefined right of prominent individuals to call the process insufficient whenever they dislike its direction.